← All topics

Topic

Critique

4 pieces

Foundations

Why AlphaZero Does Not Count as Intelligent for Bernard Jennings

AlphaZero learned through self-play to defeat leading chess, shogi, and Go programs. Bernard Jennings nevertheless excludes it from his definition of intelligence, which demands more than successful problem-solving. This article explains his classification and examines the evidence still needed for his proposal and its claimed upper limit on intelligence.

Oliver Wrede·
Foundations

Beer, Russell, and Jennings on What Comes Before Choosing an AI Model

Before deploying AI, an organization needs to decide what it should do and who can intervene when it makes mistakes. Stafford Beer explains how organizations respond to disturbances; Stuart Russell examines human control over AI. Bernard Jennings asks whether better performance amounts to greater intelligence. This essay brings their different contributions to bear on preparing an AI deployment.

Oliver Wrede·
Design Theory

Robodebt: How Estimated Income Became a Debt

Australia’s Robodebt process used longer-term income records to claim that people owed money. Software spread income evenly over shorter periods, although its actual timing was unknown. The case shows what goes wrong when a public agency treats a calculation’s assumption as an established fact.

Oliver Wrede·